Can a Trust be a Tax Effective Investment Tool

Generally trusts are taxed at the highest income tax rate of all South African tax payers. The income tax rate is set at 40% while the capital gains tax inclusion rate is set at 50%. This effectively translates to a 20% tax on capital gains made! Is there then a place for property trusts?

Not all transactions are taxed the same and not all trusts are taxed the same. Below we are going to explore some of the principles applied in using a trust as a property investment vehicle.

Special Purpose Vehicle

Some property investments may entail purchasing property and selling it again within a short space of time. Perhaps through employing sophisticated marketing methods or by restoring the property before sale, one may be able to realise a profit of such a property in a relatively short space of time.

In trust law there is an exemption against being taxed at the full income tax rate for trusts. In the event where income is earned and distributed to the beneficiaries of the trust in the same financial year, the income is taxed in the hands of the beneficiaries and not the trust. This means that the tax on the income will be at the income tax rate of the beneficiaries and not that of the trust.

Working out different scenarious will guide an investor to determining whether he should attempt the project in the name of a trust or not. The capital gains tax of the trust may sometimes be less that than the income tax payable in the hands of the beneficiaries. This will however depend on how many beneficiaries will benefit from the income, and whether they also earn other taxable income.

Often investors choose to undertake certain projects in a group. If such a project is tackled in a Partnership or Joint Venture there may be additional risk for the partners if one partner goes insolvent in the process. Protection against these risks can be afforded in the shelter of a trust. In appropriate cases, using a trust as a Special Purpose Vehicle may truly be like having your cake and eating it.

Effect of a sale on the mandate

Effect of a sale on the mandate

The effect of a sale on a management mandate agreement Is the purchaser of a property with a tenant in the premises duty-bound to perform in terms of the former landlord’s obligations towards the lease agreement, or in terms of a mandate in the case of a management mandate agreement? The lease agreement remains in […]

Court Dates

Court Dates

Obtaining court dates from the High Courts in Lockdown Level 1 As much as we, as legal practitioners, have got used to attending to court virtually and working with the new online court system, called CaseLines; the legal profession is still experiencing extreme difficulties. The latest court directives allow us to issue new proceedings at […]

RHA vs huur gaat voor koop

RHA vs huur gaat voor koop

 Does Section 4(5)(c) of the Rental Housing Act contradict the principle of huur gaat voor koop? The legal principle of huur gaat voor koop was established within Roman Dutch Law and has, since the adoption of Roman Dutch Law as the foundation of the South African legal system, been one of the cornerstone principles governing property […]

Property Rental – Level 3

Property Rental – Level 3

Why were these regulations declared unconstitutional by the High Court? What does this mean? On 2 June 2020 the High Court handed down a judgement in the matter of De Beer v COTGA. News of this judgement spread in the media and on social media like wildfire, with headings like “Lockdown Regulations Unconstitutional”; as much […]

Evictions During Level 4

Evictions During Level 4

LEVEL 4 REGULATIONS ON EVICTIONS The Alert Level 4 Regulations were released to the public explaining exactly what Level 4 will entail for the South African public. One of the regulations, specifically Regulation 19, deals with the prohibition of evictions and has a big effect on our property industry. The Regulation reads as follows: A […]

Withholding Rent During Lockdown?

Withholding Rent During Lockdown?

No regulations of any kind have been implemented to authorise tenants to refrain from paying rent. The global pandemic brought about by the COVID-19 virus has thrust South Africa into one of the most unfamiliar and uncertain times in our history, the likes of which never before experienced. Government has, in response to the virus, […]

Shares
Share This